No, an Eagle Scout board of review just isn’t meeting. The Scouting journey makes a new individual to obtain a job that is good.

The Scouting journey makes a new individual to have a good task.

But that doesn’t mean the final step up that journey — which for most young adults may be the Eagle Scout board of review — must certanly be carried out just like an appointment.

That’s the takeaway from an enlightening article that is new “Eagle Scout Boards of Review: perhaps Not really employment interview.” You’ll find it into the November-December 2018 problem of “Advancement News,” a publication that is official the BSA’s nationwide Advancement Program Team.

“The Scouts have previously ‘earned the position’ of Eagle Scout by finishing certain requirements,” the read article states. “They are not interviewing for the position.”

Therefore rather than treating the Eagle Scout board of review as an opportunity to grill the young person, test their abilities or ask “gotcha” concerns, you really need to “make it one thing become proud to talk about with other people, not at all something become feared.”

Browse the complete piece below. It’s worth your time and effort. As a result of Wayne Huddleston and Mike Lo Vecchio of this nationwide Advancement Program Team for permitting us to here share it.

What’s a board of review? Here’s a fast reminder.

A board of review is the opportunity for grownups to talk to Scouts as to what they’ve done, exactly exactly what they’ve learned, just just how has they were helped by it within their development and just how they’re experiencing the system.

It’s needed for every rank from Tenderfoot to Eagle Scout. (But, at the time of Aug. 1, 2017, it is no more necessary for the Eagle palms.)

It’s an opportunity to commemorate what’s occurring and respond to questions in regards to the future. But, as you’ll read, there’s one thing it is most surely maybe perhaps not.

Eagle Scout Boards of Review: Maybe Maybe Not Really a working Appointment

Initially posted within the November-December 2018 problem of “Advancement News,” a publication that is official the BSA’s nationwide Advancement Program Team.

Sporadically we hear of Eagle Scout panels of review which have been changed into one thing they certainly were never ever designed to be.

For instance, some have actually stated that the board of review is much like meeting. absolutely Nothing might be further through the truth.

The Scouts have “earned the position” of Eagle Scout by doing certain requirements. They’re not interviewing for the positioning.

All all too often, the “job meeting” analogy is employed to justify quantity of additional requirements that aren’t appropriate.

Expecting the Scout to appear in “business attire,” grilling them on the skills, asking improper concerns designed to cause panic and anxiety may all seem justified as making the Scout better prepared for expertise in the “real globe.”

But, the Scout is already into the “real globe” of Scouting. The board of review just isn’t about planning the Scout for one thing but alternatively about celebrating their achievements.

While area of the board’s responsibility is always to ensure that requirements have now been met, it’s not their duty to find out if those demands came across the board’s individual standards.

Other youth leaders and grownups who formerly reviewed the Scout determined that the demands had been met once they finalized down regarding the requirement, or merit badge, etc. It is really not as much as the board to determine that the requirements employed by those leaders had been or weren’t enough.

Because of the time Scouts reach the Eagle Scout board of review, these have demonstrated their knowledge and abilities, several times over. This prospect is through all intents and purposes an Eagle Scout whenever reaching the board of review. Just within the many cases that are egregious it had been clear that the Scout could perhaps not perhaps have correctly finished a necessity would the board be warranted in determining that the Scout really should not be advanced level.

Consequently, make the Scout’s Eagle board of review a party of these accomplishment. Allow it to be one thing to be proud to fairly share with other people, not at all something become feared.

It is really not a working meeting; it’s a party of the work done well.

More guidance for boards of review

See Section 8 of this help Guide to development to get more insight that is great panels of review.